We tasted Auchentoshan, Macallan (sherry cask, I think it was called “Excellencia”), Laphroaig and Bowmore.
We thought that the Laphroaig was the best one, and that the others was almost equal. It was interesting that the Laphroaig made the Bowmore rather lame. When comparing it to Laphroaig you could only barely recognize the peaty smell.